“Goodnight you princes of Maine, you kings of New England”

cider house rulesI’ve just finished reading John Irving’s The Cider House Rules. I feel a bizarre sense of ‘loss’ that it has taken me so many years to finally read this book. And it was something of an impulse – picking it up from the library at the beginning of September. I should have read it 20 years ago.

It is a masterpiece; desperately good; devastatingly evocative; though sorrowful and deep; not what I would call ‘feel-good reading’. But so epic; so sweeping. There aren’t all that many genuinely 5*+ books, but this is one of them. John Irving is – for me – an absolute master storyteller. His ability to create characters that truly come alive – and who live on in your mind, long, long after you’ve finished reading the book – is his enduring power. I can’t quite describe it.

The depiction of St Clouds (the isolated, Victorian-esque orphanage in rural Maine, where much of the novel is set) – triggered some of the most powerful flashbacks to my early years at boarding school – itself an isolated, old, Victorian assortment of buildings on the top of a windswept hill in rural Southern England. There was a boys division and a girls division, too. The parallels with the nurses (our boys dormitory adjoined the ‘san’ (sanitorium, the medical wing) were so strong; as was the parallel between Mrs Grogan and the kindly Irish matron we ourselves had, called Miss Coin. To be clear – I am not and thus was not – an ‘orphan’. But even so. There are parallels with ‘that life’ when as a child you grow up without your family. So it resonated on many levels and awakened memories that had lain dormant for almost two decades.

I first discovered John Irving way back, when I was a university student in Massachusetts, New England, in the mid 1990s. A person I was in love with (a long story and certainly beyond the scope of this blog; he was a Swede) had said to me that a book called A Prayer for Owen Meany had changed his life. I took that with a rather large pinch of salt but I did end up getting it out of the library. It was – and perhaps remains – the most unforgettable book I had ever read. I never talk about the book’s content or try to ‘unpick’ it; I’d much rather let others experience it for themselves, without letting them form preconceptions beforehand.

Wilbur Larch and Homer Wells (the two central characters in The Cider House Rules) now join Owen Meany and Johnny Wheelwright (from A Prayer for Owen Meany) in that pantheon within my mind – that special place where they will live on, in perpetuity.

As an aside – I came across this long, and interesting, Telegraph interview with John Irving from last year; it’s definitely worth reading.

5 thoughts on ““Goodnight you princes of Maine, you kings of New England”

Add yours

  1. @Kate Definitely do read it. A friend has seen the movie which he said was ‘okay’ and I keep telling him the book is amazing. I don’t really want to see the movie now as I don’t think it could live up to the book (and I believe JI left out characters and other plot lines, as he had to, to get it to fit).

    @Vern Yes, brilliant is the word! I’m going to read ‘In One Person’ next.

  2. I much prefer the book to the movie adaptation of this. Let me know what you think of ‘In One Person’ – I believe that is why Irving was doing a lot of press last year. I didn’t care for the book much. I loved his earlier books much more.

    1. Yeh, S said he’d seen the film and that it was “so/so” and I thought: you cannot be saying that about this amazing book! But of course, they’re never the same. Shame to hear his recent book not as good. But then, ‘Garp’ did’t do it for me although most others rate that above all his others. I’m half way through Jane Eyre which I just want to finish now!!! Only ready that due to the endless references of it in ‘Cider House Rules’.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Blog at WordPress.com.

Up ↑

%d bloggers like this: